20 Oct Why Gas Stations are Better than Tow Trucks
Sometimes my student teachers ask me: “Can you show me how you plan?”
This question always sets me back a little because my process, like that of many teachers, is not exactly black and white. I think this is (roughly) how I plan: I obsess about my students constantly, I think about them in the grocery store, on the subway, and making dinner. I think about them as I am falling asleep, and I think about them when I wake up. It is not that I am worrying, persay, its that I am “marinating” in who they are, what they do, what they love and what they need. Simultaneously, I think and read (also somewhat obsessively- if only I could this kind of enthusiasm around cleaning the bathroom) about what makes people active, independent, confident, and successful in the world, not just on report cards. Sometimes, oftentimes in the shower or on the subway, these two thought cycles collide and a big picture goal emerges – and then bit by bit it gets whittled into bite size ideas that fit into squares in a plan book. (Sorry student teachers past and present, it’s not just a Tuesday afternoon thing). Often times (every time) things do not go the way I planned, and so back to the planning boxes to fix up or skip ahead.
And yes, I think about the common core state standards, and the benchmarks for learning, and all the other things that make up a curriculum.
So After All That, What is My Big Idea RIGHT Now?
Truly and honestly, after all this obsessive thinking, I have come to believe its how students meet the standards that really matters. Thinking about the range of children I have worked with over the years, some have been persistent, resilient, optimistic and flexible, others have been rigid, fearful, and passive in their learning. Have both met benchmark? Well yes and no, they may both read on level, but what about the benchmark for having a successful life? If I (metaphorically) scaffold and drag and tug a child to benchmark, have they really made it? What happens to that child in the world?
Perhaps an analogy here: If a child is a car, and the standards are stops along the road that need to be reached, persistence, resilience, flexibility, and optimism are the gas (or electricity if you have a hybrid, so PC of me, no?) that help children reach the sign posts on their own. The teacher cannot be the tow truck that drags a child through each standard, even if it gets them there faster, but we can be the gas station attendant or roadside assistance that provides fuel, feedback, and a reassuring pat on the back so they get there on their own…and keep going. Sometimes I wonder if the kids who have the greatest summer reading loss are the kids who got dragged to benchmark in the first place. (And trust me, I have dragged my fair share of kids to benchmark.)
Everything I have been reading supports the idea that persistence, more than IQ, is what makes for success, but few things tell me HOW to fit this big idea onto squares in my plan book. How do I plan to be a gas station, not a tow truck? Two posts ago, I thought of some general guidelines for my teaching this year, last post I began to lay out what I am putting in my planning squares. This week I am continuing that thread- which is the whole purpose of this blog- the real time collision of theory and practice.
As a class, we now have a few big ideas about what makes a brain grow- persistence, resilience, flexibility, and optimism (safety and kindness also popped up in there) and the main work we have been doing is retroactive naming, “I was persistent when I…” The thought that has been rolling around in my brain is how to shift from retroactive to proactive- If I have an intention, or a goal, to be kind, I am more likely to live that way. Simultaneously I have just started reading Tools of the Mind (get it, buy it, read it- so far I am mesmerized) which has me thinking about children setting play and learning plans. With children setting their own intentions, I am relegated to a supporting role, no dragging or towing allowed. So with the help of my incredible kindergarten team: Valerie Geschwind, Mollie Gaffney, Kathryn Cazes, and Katie Lee, here is what is on the next few planning squares:
What We Did:
- Taught symbols that represent each big idea we have studied. I said, “Symbols are pictures that mean something, like a red slash over something means ‘no’ and all the brain growers we have been learning about can have symbols too!”
We did this on a small piece of paper under the document camera. My team originally thought of these symbols to make it easier for kids to code for them in their work and to refer to them, some teachers taught them along with the original read aloud, I waited, for no particular reason other than it felt like a lot happening at once. In teaching simple symbols, children can own a way to indicate the skill without me. In giving them this tool, I am gassing them up, not tugging them.
After making this list, my next plan for the symbols is to make a bigger 3 column chart: the word, followed by a picture of the character we studied in read aloud, followed by the symbol. Although kids remembered a few of the symbols, they need the intermediary step of the character since not many of them are reading the word “flexible”.
What We Did:
- Taught learning plans. I did this first as an activity following morning meeting. First I modeled my thought process of the brain grower(s) I might need for the few parts of the day on the plan, then kids went off to do it while my assistant teacher and I coached into their ideas.
This thinker opted to work on being kind during writing (sharing materials, etc), safe at lunch, persistent at choice time, and resilient at reading. You may also note that I provided the symbols for everything but choice time (I have my doodles as a font on my computer- see chartchums.wordpress.com and search for technology to find out how), and this thinker put scissors to remind her that that square is for choice time. The tow truck option here would be to tell children what they need to do in each part of the day, but instead most children set goals for themselves that I tended to agree with and the self selected method feels better to me.
- After a few more whole class attempts, this will shift over to be a child’s morning work in the classroom. It gets taped to their spot for easy reflection (although their thinking spots in reading and writing are not the same… so I am still working that part out)
- More parts of the day will go on the learning plan
What We Did:
- Reflected. At the end of each time, I modeled my own thinking of how I met the goal and drew a picture as “evidence”. Let’s be clear, some kids did a little wishful thinking here, but I will take it for now.
This thinker wanted to be safe and kind in writing, and her reflection shows that she safely gave an ABC chart to another child.
- Because some children were wishful in their goal fulfillment sketches, more mid-work breaks are needed to have children self-talk their way through their goals.
- Children need oral rehearsal before they can go off and draw (or write) so giving them time to turn and tell their neighbor the way they met their goal before they draw will make some of their reflections better
- Yes, of course some children filled out the entire reflection side before they actually did the goals. I applaud their ambition, but am teaching them the way the system really works.
- I let parents in on this for two reasons: this allows a parent and child to have a meaningful conversation about the day. The paper is concrete and I sent the symbols home to the parents so they would know if the child forgot. And two: parents can mimic this at home: what is your goal for your piano practice today?
- I am worried slightly about the time of all this, as in the first day it took a long time. I get that that it will get faster, I am just being honest. It is incredibly worthwhile, but sometimes EVERYTHING seems worthwhile.
Of course, I am dying to know what you are doing to build these skills in your classrooms! Let me know what you think about what we are trying, and what is working for you!